Feeding Chaff and Chaff/Straw Feedstuffs to Beef Cows

1. Background
Chaff and chaff/straw combinations are commonly used as low‑cost roughage sources for mature beef cows. Their nutritional value depends heavily on crop type, harvest method, and handling practices. These feeds are best suited for cows in good body condition during mid‑gestation, as they primarily provide maintenance-level energy.

 
2. Collection, Handling, and Feeding Methods
Chaff Collection Options
  1. Dropped onto the straw swath (cyclone attachment)
    • Collected directly into the swath and baled.
    • Requires minimal equipment and is simple to manage.
    • Baled chaff can be fed via round bale feeders, rolled out, or tub-ground and mixed with other feeds.
  2. Collected with a chaff wagon
    • Blown into a wagon and dropped in piles for field grazing or later hauling.
    • Allows flexible feeding but requires more handling.
Field Feeding
  • Chaff piles can be grazed in-field or moved to a central location.
  • Field feeding is low-cost and efficient, requiring fencing and access to water (snow or dugout).
  • Minimizes yardage and manure accumulation in feeding areas.
Corral Feeding
  • More costly due to transportation of bulky material.
  • Removal of chaff may result in thick straw mats and potential weed problems the next season.
  • Chaff piles can be transported using a forage harvester or loader-mounted hay sweep.
  • Can be fed mixed with other roughages or offered free-choice with electric‑wire access control.
Mixing with Silage
  • Improves ration balance and extends winter feed supplies.
  • Helps match nutrient supply with cow requirements.
  • Transportation remains the major limiting cost because chaff is light and bulky.
Potential Feeding Issues
  • Rough-awned barley chaff may cause mouth ulcers.
  • Planning based on feed type helps prevent animal health problems.

 
3. Feed Testing
Chaff quality varies widely due to:
  • Crop type and maturity
  • Weed content
  • Harvest method and combine settings
  • Field conditions
Feed testing ensures rations meet minimum requirements and supports economical supplementation decisions. 20 samples per field are recommended.
Sampling Procedures
  • Baled chaff or chaff/straw:
    • Use a core sampler and take samples from the middle of each end,
    • Collect 20 samples from various round bales or one per rectangular bale.
  • Chaff piles:
    • Hand-sample different locations and depths.
    • Combine and sub-sample ~2 L for analysis.
  • Ensure sample represents both light and heavy fractions; request full-sample grinding at the lab.
Most labs analyze:
  • Crude protein, ADF, NDF, Calcium, phosphorus and energy (TDN)
Trace mineral testing every 2–3 years helps evaluate supplementation programs.
Wet chemistry testing is more accurate than NIR, especially for lower-quality feeds.

 
4. Feeding Chaff: Quality and Nutritional Considerations
Factors Affecting Chaff Quality
  • Combine settings: More grain passing to chaff increases feeding value.
  • Combine efficiency: Poor efficiency increases cracked grain and unthreshed heads.
  • Underseeding (e.g., alfalfa): Adds green leaf and protein.
  • Harvest stage: More broken straw = lower quality.
  • Crop height/moisture: Short crops add more straw, reducing nutrient density.

 
5. Feed Value of Chaff
Average values from 200+ samples
  • Wheat chaff: Low protein (4–5%), moderate fibre, low TDN (≈40–44%).
  • Barley chaff: Higher protein (5–7%), higher TDN (≈53%).
  • Oat chaff: Highest protein (≈7%) and TDN (≈53%).
  • Canola chaff: Higher fibre, lower energy (≈38.5% TDN).
  • Pea chaff: Higher protein (≈7–9%) but moderate energy (≈40–42%).

 
6. Meeting Nutritional Requirements
Chaff and chaff/straw mixtures are suitable only for mature cows in good condition.
Example requirement:
  • A 1,400 lb cow (BCS 3.5) needs:
    • ≥6.5% crude protein
    • ~54% TDN
Most chaff types fall below these thresholds, especially in CP and TDN, so protein supplementation is essential.
Protein Supplementation
Benefits include:
  • Improved dry matter intake
  • Enhanced rumen microbial activity
  • Better digestion of low‑quality roughage
  • Improved weight and condition maintenance over winter
Supplements increase ruminal NH₃, promoting microbial growth and fibre digestion.
Selecting a Supplement
Many options exist; choice depends on:
  • Feed inventory
  • Cost
  • Feeding system
  • Cow nutrient requirements
Producers should consult a nutritionist or beef specialist to determine the most cost‑effective program.